The Truth About Pit Bulls by Chad Mackin

The Truth About Pit Bulls by Chad Mackin

The Truth About Pit Bulls was written by internationally acknowledged dog trainer Chad Mackin and reposted with his permission. Please check out Chad’s online sources below. Consider subscribing to his podcast “Something to Bark About” and following him on Facebook. Dog owners and dog trainers equally enjoy his thoughtful insights.

This is the most thorough description of the nature of pit bulls I have read to date, and I couldn’t have said any of this better, which is why I asked Chad’s permission to publish it on my site. This post includes references to dogfighting, as this is part of the breed’s history. Still, in no way, shape or form should any part of this post be interpreted as an endorsement or apology for this horrible activity or the people who engage(d) in it.

The post also references the book Dogs of Velvet and Steel by Bob Stevens. This book was not written by a stellar human being, as he did engage in dogfighting himself, as I understand. However, this book is considered the best resource for understanding pit bulls written to date. It shouldn’t be necessary to clarify these things up front, but this is the Internet, and I know it needs to be spelled out for some.

The Truth About Pit Bulls by Chad Mackin

I’ve seen a lot of posts about pit bulls lately. Some are written to defend them, others on why their history makes them more dangerous than other dogs. Almost everything I’ve read misses the point in big ways. So, let’s get our hands dirty and get into some controversy, shall we?

If you take to either of the following lines about pit bulls, you are probably not going to like what I will say.

Contrary to what many believe, it isn’t all about how you raise them. The fact that pit bulls were originally bred for fighting doesn’t automatically make them aggressive. And no, they were never (as far as I can tell) called “Nanny Dogs,” but I can think of no dog with better skills to be trusted around children than an old-school fighting pit dog.

This is a simple fact that should be obvious to everyone who knows anything about dogs and dog breeding. Anytime we make a blanket statement about a breed’s temperament, we will be wrong about a large portion of individuals. The further we move away from purpose breeding, the less we can count on temperament.

Breed Purpose

Yet, pit bull apologists, advocates, and detractors equally pretend this isn’t true. They don’t seem to understand that generations of random breeding led to wildly varying temperaments. Obviously, there is a difference between the results of purpose breeding and random breeding. How could it be otherwise?

Few pit bulls are purpose-bred these days, and even fewer are bred for fighting—thankfully. This means there no longer is a consistent temperament in the breed.

The modern pit bull is as likely to be a couch potato as he is to be dangerously aggressive.

Dog Fighting

We must first understand what they were bred to do to understand this. It’s not as easy as saying, “They were bred to fight,” unless we understand what dog fighting was actually about. When we hear of dog fighting, most of us think of what Michael Vick was convicted of doing. That is dog fighting, but it bears almost no relation to the type of dog fighting pit bulls were bred for. Let me stress before I go further; there is no “good” way to fight dogs. It’s always wrong, and it always has been wrong. Nothing I say in the following should be interpreted as a defense of dog fighting. However, we cannot understand what makes pit bulls without understanding the task they were bred to perform.

Gameness

Traditionally, dogfighting wasn’t a test of the dog’s fighting ability. The old pit men fought their dogs to test for a trait called “gameness.” Gameness is a particular type of tenacity in the face of adversity. The idea of the game dog is a dog who, once dedicated to a task, will never stop trying, no matter how hard it gets. As one dogfighter put it,

Gameness is not the willingness to fight. It’s not the courage to be killed by a better opponent. It’s the will to win.

According to the old pit bull books, this will to win, this gameness, should be stronger than the dog’s will to survive. And this trait was what the pit bull was bred for, above all else. It was this trait that dogfighting was supposed to test. The rules of the old dog fights reflect this. If a dog’s owner stopped a battle because his dog was losing and refused to quit, his reputation as a dog man wasn’t tainted by that. His dog wasn’t the best fighter, but he never stopped trying to win, and that was the exact trait they were looking for.

This, above all else, is what makes a good pit bull. That single-mindedness of purpose when the chips are down should be the breed’s hallmark.

Gameness vs. Aggression

Unfortunately, many confuse gameness with aggression, which is not a new problem. Reading old pit bull books or magazine articles, the authors have to remind the reader a few times that aggression and gameness aren’t necessarily related. Consider this passage from the book “Dogs of Velvet and Steel”:

Folks who don’t know much about pit bulls, are inclined to consider aggressiveness to be gameness. As I mentioned earlier, there is no correlation between the two. Many dogs of other breeds will aggressively snarl, attack, and bite. The game dog will stay and fight no matter how hard he is bitten or tossed around. The dog that is not game will give up when bitten hard enough or after fighting a relatively short time without winning. The point is this – the dog who is aggressive is not necessarily game – and the dog who is passive may be the gamest one in ten counties.

Aggression wasn’t selected against, but according to all the sources I can find, it wasn’t particularly sought after either, at least not by the most knowledgeable minds.

However, there are many traits a dog could be bred for that would help him in a fight, and there’s no way they wouldn’t have been selected for, along with that cardinal trait of gameness.

Other Pit Bull Traits

For a pit bull to be successful, he had to enjoy conflict. It doesn’t matter how game he is if he doesn’t set his mind to winning the fight. So a desire to engage in conflict was essential. But that doesn’t necessarily mean a fight. It merely means overcoming resistance. A game dog might grab hold of a tree root and spend hours trying to pull it from the ground. This is one of the reasons weight pull remains a favorite sport for pit bulls.

A successful pit dog would also have to have a high pain tolerance. It’s all well and good that the dog won’t quit no matter how tough the going gets, but the less pain bothers him, the longer he can go before not stopping requires gameness. So dogs who were mostly immune to pain had a distinct advantage.

A fighting dog would also benefit from being physically powerful.

Social Attachment

The above traits were beneficial but, strictly speaking, not necessary. Finally, there was one non-negotiable quality. A fighting dog had to have an incredible social attachment to humans. The attachment had to be strong enough to create an extreme aversion to biting humans. Not just humans he knows, but any humans. There were always three people in the pit during a dog fight, two of them often entirely unknown to the dog.

These people would have to handle the dog while he’s in full drive and possibly when he’s injured. If the dog posed any threat, he would not be permitted into the pit. In fact, he would not be allowed to live. The old pitmen had no tolerance for human aggression. Dogs who showed the slightest hint of it were culled without hesitation. They were playing a dangerous game and understood the consequences of having a dog with the abilities of a fighting dog, who decided to turn those traits towards human prey.

The Modern-Day Pit Bull

And that brings us to the modern world of pit bulls.

The absence of purpose breeding means most pit bulls are a grab bag of traits. Most of the ones I have met in my career would be better described as pet bulls. The most conflict they want is a little bit of tug or chasing a treat. They are generally happy being couch potatoes. They have strong social attachments, which is why pit bull advocates and apologists are so vigorous in their defense of the breed. Few dogs will love you as much as a good pit bull because few have been selected for that trait as much as they were.

If you have a pit bull who is physically tough, has a strong social attachment to humans, and is game about that attachment, you may have the ideal dog for children to interact with. They are going to be more tolerant of the clumsiness of the child. If the child pulls an ear or pokes an eye, that dog is far less likely to bite the kid than a less game, socially attached, and physically tough dog. Of course, you should NEVER rely on the dog to make good judgments around kids. I’m not suggesting anything otherwise. But I do think this is where the Nanny Dog idea comes from. The margin for error in allowing interactions between dog and child is more substantial with the dog I’ve described above than with a dog without those traits.

If, on the other hand, you get a dog who loves conflict, is physically strong and game, but lacks that sort of social attachment to humans, you legitimately have a potential nightmare on your hands. It really can go either way.

The Lack of Purpose Breeding

However, I find that if the dogs aren’t bred for a purpose, most end up in the pet bull category. This makes sense because gameness isn’t a great survival strategy, especially at the level the old dogs were bred to. The dogs who make it to reproductive age are more likely than not to be the ones who are easiest to live with. That’s human behavior.

At this point in history, however, there is no standard pit bull temperament, at least not one you can count on. I believe there are so many conflicting reports about pit bulls due to the lack of purpose breeding. The dogs are changing, and not necessarily in good ways.

A Sport for Pit Bulls

Thankfully, there is hope for the pit bull. There is a new sport designed to encourage owners to develop and celebrate the traits that made pit bulls such great dogs years ago—without the bloodshed. It’s called GRC, which stands for Gameness, Relationship, and Control. The sport stresses social responsibility (relationship and control) along with gameness. I believe this sport is the best thing to happen to the breed since fighting them was outlawed. While it was designed with pit bulls in mind, it’s open to all breeds. If you want more information about it, you can go to GRC Dog Sports.

Chad Mackin

Chad’s Website: PackToBasics.net

Chad’s Podcast: Something to Bark About

Chad on Facebook: Chad’s Profile

Chad Mackin is an internationally acknowledged dog trainer of 27 years, founder and owner of the dog training company Pack To Basics, former president of the International Association of Canine Professionals and head trainer of 4 Paws Activity Center.

Category: General Information Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Related Articles

 

You May Also Like ...

These are some of our most popular articles. You may like them as well. Check them out!

Services and Area

We are located in Southern California and train dogs nationwide. Happy Dog Training currently offers local dog training services in the following counties. Riverside County, Orange County, San Bernardino County, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County. In addition, we offer our board-and-train program nationwide and all virtual training services worldwide.

Do you want your new puppy trained right from the start? Are you looking for help for your fearful dog? Do you need to resolve a severe aggression problem? You came to the right place! We are experienced, professional dog trainers. Ralf has trained over 1500 dogs in over 18 years, and Sarah has trained over 1200 dogs in over 11 years. Consequently, we can help you with any dog training goal.

What We Offer

For many of our clients, we train their dogs from puppyhood, getting them off to a great start. However, we also have extensive experience training rescue dogs from all imaginable backgrounds and circumstances. Our Board-and-Train program is our most popular.

We can help you, regardless of your dog's challenges or training goals. Being a professional dog trainer means having experience, knowledge, and skill. Further, we developed a highly effective training program to specifically help fearful dogs gain more confidence and become the best possible version of themselves. Building Confidence is our second most popular training program.

Last but not least, we are experts in dealing with all types of aggression in dogs and are often the trainers of last resort after many other programs have failed. Most of our aggressive dog clients previously spent significant money on half-baked solutions without much improvement. This is different from us. We will give you an honest assessment of what goals are realistic for your dog. We will tell you what can be resolved reliably and what likely needs to be managed before we start.

Our flagship product is our board and train program. But our virtual dog training and coaching services have become quite popular over the last couple of years. Our setup enables us to deliver online dog training services from our indoor and outdoor training areas. This allows us to help clients worldwide.

Other Resources

Also, check out our Free Dog Training tips on Separation Anxiety in Dogs, Potty Training aka Housebreaking, and Leash Handling for expert solutions to common challenges.

Additional Services: Presentations and Q&As on Dogs | Professional Service Dog Training

Contact Us and Start Training

Finally, once you're ready to move forward, please use our dog training contact form to schedule a free phone consultation or book a paid, in-person consultation.

Terms, Conditions and Privacy Policy

By using this website you agree to all Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy.

About Ralf and Sarah

Happy Dog Training is the pet dog training business of Ralf Weber and Sarah Gill. We are certified professional dog trainers in Southern California. We are specialized in advanced obedience training, all forms or behavioral challenges and service dog training. For behavioral training, we are known for our work with aggressive and fearful dogs. Our service dogs, through Total K9 Focus, have a nationwide reputation for their reliability, longevity and performance.

Ralf Weber, MS, TWC CPDT, IACP CDT, CDTA

Certified Professional Dog Trainer Ralf Weber is lead pet dog trainer of Happy Dog Training. Ralf is a long-time dog owner of German Shepherds. During his career, Ralf has worked with over a 1500 dogs of many different breeds. Moreover, Ralf has a thorough understanding of all aspects of canine training. This includes evolutionary psychology, ethology, and, most importantly, learning science. Ralf is specialized in resolving dog behavior challenges—especially fear and aggression. Apart from this, Ralf trains dogs in basic and advanced obedience, service dog tasks, and GRC Dog Sports. Ralf is further certified in a broad range of other canine training areas. Last but not least, Ralf is the author of the behavioral book If Your Dog Could Talk: Understand Your Dog Like Never Before.

Ralf loves helping people have a better relationship with their dogs. He is a certified professional dog trainer in the Training without Conflict™ methodology by Ivan Balabanov (TWC CPDT). Ralf is also a member of the International Association of Canine Professionals and also holds their basic and advanced dog trainer certifications (IACP CDT, CDTA). In addition, Ralf is an AKC-approved evaluator for the AKC Puppy Star, CGC, and Advanced CGC programs and is also certified in canine first aid by the Red Cross.

Sarah Gill, Certified Professional Master Trainer

Sarah Gill, is a professional service dog trainer and handler. Sarah entered the world of professional service dog training after a car accident. As a result, she had to use a wheelchair for almost two years, trying to maneuver in a house not designed for it. No one expected Sarah would walk again. This opened her eyes and became a driving force behind pushing herself to defy the odds. When she regained some stability, Sarah attended a dog training school and learned how to train service dogs. Sarah completed her Master Trainer Certification and gained further experience by training new trainers. However, the school wasn’t accommodating to those with physical difficulties and PTSD. Hence, Sarah moved home to Dallas. In 2019, Sarah teamed up with Ralf and moved to California.

Sarah started this journey because she had a trained dog to mitigate her disabilities. But Sarah needed additional tasking for a new diagnosis. The only option she could find was getting a second dog for the new diagnosis. She knew there had to be a different way to address this. Sarah's passion is changing the ways of the service dog training industry.